Can a Judge Hold Me in "Direct Contempt" Just for a Positive Drug Test in Court? | The Law Corner | Raleigh, NC

The Law Corner

Precedent Case: State v. Aspiote, N.C. App., S.E.2d (May 21, 2025). 


Direct criminal contempt The trial court erred when it held defendant in direct criminal contempt after he tested positive for an impairing substance during a criminal court proceeding. Where there was nothing in the record to show defendant lied to the court about taking an impairing substance, or that he was impaired during the proceeding, or that he intentionally caused a delay in the process for testing him for an impaired substance, the trial court erred in concluding defendant committed direct criminal contempt. 


The trial court held the defendant in direct criminal contempt after refusing to accept the defendant’s plea in criminal court because the defendant tested positive for drug use during the plea proceeding. The trial court concluded that the defendant caused a delay in the court proceedings by telling the court that he would not test positive for an impairing substance and by intentionally delaying the drug testing process. 



The court of appeals reversed the contempt order after concluding that the record showed the defendant admitted to taking an impairing substance on the day of the proceeding, did not say he would not test positive for a substance, and was not impaired during the proceeding. The court of appeals also held that the defendant could not be in direct criminal contempt for intentionally delaying the testing process because the testing occurred outside of the courtroom and outside the presence of the judge.

You might also like...

Scales of justice on a table, with a gavel.
By The Law Corner November 20, 2025
Learn why criminal contempt is not subject to the 2-year statute of limitations, meaning old violations of a court order can still be punished.
Inside a courtroom: Judge's bench with American flag, wood paneling, computers.
By The Law Corner November 20, 2025
Explore the technical requirements for a civil contempt order in North Carolina. And learn what a "purge payment" is.
Woman in black dress cries outside a white door while a man in a black suit gestures angrily.
By The Law Corner November 20, 2025
Learn the difference between civil contempt (force someone to stop an ongoing violation) & criminal contempt (punish someone for a past violation of a court order).
Back to Blog

Arrange a Consultation with The Law Corner